Eren's Unstoppable Titan: What if Gabi Never Fired?

27 Sep 2024

Imagine a world where the rumbling proceeded unchecked. A world where Eren Yeager, within the colossal skeletal frame of the Founding Titan, achieved his chilling vision. This alternate timeline hinges on a single moment: Gabi Braun missing her shot. What if Eren's Founding Titan form remained whole, its terrible power unleashed upon the world? The ramifications would have been earth-shattering, reshaping the very fabric of the Attack on Titan narrative.

Had Gabi's bullet not severed Eren's head from his Founding Titan form, the devastation he intended would have likely become a horrifying reality. The global eradication of life outside Paradis Island, the chilling objective of the rumbling, would have been agonizingly close to completion. The remaining survivors, scattered and traumatized, would face a bleak and desolate future.

This alternate scenario isn't simply a thought experiment; it highlights the fragility of hope in a world teetering on the brink of destruction. It emphasizes the significance of individual actions, how a single bullet can alter the course of history. The weight of Gabi's choice, successful in the original narrative, takes on an entirely new dimension when viewed through the lens of what might have been.

Examining the hypothetical scenario where Eren's Founding Titan form persists offers a fascinating insight into the narrative structure of Attack on Titan. It allows us to consider the potential consequences of Eren's unimpeded power, pushing the story's themes of freedom, sacrifice, and the cyclical nature of violence to their extremes. The very notion underscores the magnitude of the stakes involved.

Eren’s ultimate transformation, this monstrous skeletal form connected to countless Wall Titans, was a terrifying spectacle of power. The image of this near-godlike being, capable of reshaping the world in his image, is a stark representation of the devastating potential held within the Founding Titan. Had this form remained untouched, the very balance of power, not just within the walls but globally, would have been irrevocably altered.

The ramifications of Eren's unimpeded Founding Titan form are vast and complex. The world beyond Paradis Island would likely have been decimated, with minimal chance of resistance against the colossal Wall Titans. This begs the question: what would have become of the remaining Eldians on Paradis Island? Would they truly have found freedom, or merely exchanged one form of oppression for another, living under the shadow of Eren's terrifying power? This scenario also throws into sharp relief the moral complexities of Eren's actions, forcing us to confront the devastating consequences of his pursuit of freedom, no matter the cost.

One could speculate on various potential outcomes. Perhaps some form of Eldian empire would have risen from the ashes, ruled by Eren or those loyal to his vision. Alternatively, perhaps internal conflicts within Paradis Island, fueled by dissent and the trauma of the rumbling, would have erupted, leading to further chaos and destruction. This hypothetical outcome throws a dark shadow over any notion of a peaceful resolution.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Eren's Complete Rumbling

Advantages (from Eren's perspective)	Disadvantages
Elimination of external threats to Paradis Island	Global genocide, an act of unimaginable cruelty
Ensuring the survival of the Eldian people (at least initially)	Destruction of cultures and societies beyond Paradis
Absolute control over the world's future (from Eren's viewpoint)	Moral corruption of Paradis Island, stained by the weight of their survival

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. Could anyone have stopped Eren if Gabi missed? Potentially, other Titan shifters working together might have posed a threat, but it would have been an incredibly difficult battle.

2. What would be the long-term impact on the environment? Catastrophic. The sheer number of colossal titans trampling the earth would have caused widespread ecological devastation.

3. Would Eren have maintained control of the Founding Titan indefinitely? Unclear. The strain of such power is immense, and it's possible he would have lost control or been overthrown.

4. What kind of world would Paradis Island become after the rumbling? Likely a militaristic and isolated nation, possibly fractured by internal conflict.

5. Would Eren have regretted his actions? This is a question at the heart of Eren's character and motivations, and one left open to interpretation.

6. Could anyone else have inherited the Founding Titan after Eren? This depends on the specific circumstances and whether Eren had any intentions regarding succession.

7. Would any other nations or civilizations survive the rumbling? Highly unlikely, given the scale of destruction.

8. How would history remember Eren Yeager in this scenario? As a liberator, a tyrant, or a destroyer? Likely a complex and controversial figure.

Reflecting on this 'what if' scenario underscores the intricate web of cause and effect within Attack on Titan's narrative. The near-apocalyptic vision of Eren's unchecked Founding Titan power paints a chilling portrait of a world reshaped by violence. It serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of peace and the devastating potential for destruction when unchecked power is wielded. The ripple effects of Gabi's missed shot, had it occurred, would have redefined the very meaning of freedom and survival in the Attack on Titan world, leaving a legacy of destruction and posing profound moral questions for generations to come. Understanding this alternate timeline helps us appreciate the complexities of the story's conclusion and the weight of the choices made by its characters.